How Roof Age Is Affecting Home Insurance Coverage and Premiums
HomeWalk Friendly Guide
How Roof Age Is Affecting Home Insurance Coverage and Premiums
Homeowners are being surprised at renewal time: higher premiums, new roof exclusions, or even non‑renewal notices. A common thread in many of these stories is one detail that used to feel routine: roof age.
Insurers across the country are tightening their rules around older roofs. Age bands like 10, 15, and 20 years are showing up in underwriting guidelines, rate calculations, and coverage limits.[^1] That means the age of your roof can now affect not just how much you pay, but whether you can get or keep coverage at all.
In this guide, you will learn:
- How insurers use roof age to price and limit coverage
- Why older roofs often get Actual Cash Value (ACV) instead of full replacement
- State trends, including what is happening in places like Florida, Connecticut, and beyond
- Practical steps you can take now to protect both your roof and your insurance options
If you are buying a home or approaching renewal, understanding this topic can save you real money and major headaches.
1. Why insurers care so much about roof age
Your roof is one of the most expensive parts of your home to repair or replace. It is also one of the first things damaged in storms, especially wind and hail. Insurance companies have decades of loss data showing that as roofs age, claims get more likely and more expensive.
Recent research from the Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety (IBHS) shows that even short‑term natural weathering measurably reduces the impact resistance of asphalt shingles, especially to hail.[^8] Repeated hail makes that decline even faster. In hail‑ and storm‑prone regions, this helps explain why insurers track roof age so closely.
Many companies now group roofs into age bands such as:[^1][^6]
- 0 to 10 years: Lowest perceived risk, often eligible for best rates and broadest coverage
- 11 to 15 years: Closer scrutiny, more documentation, and rising premiums
- 16 to 20 years: More inspections, possible coverage limits or higher deductibles
- 20+ years: Highest risk category, with increased chance of non‑renewal or reduced coverage
From an insurer’s standpoint, an older roof is more likely to leak, lose shingles in a storm, or suffer serious hail damage. So they either charge more, limit what they will pay, or sometimes decline to insure altogether.
What this means for you: Your roof’s age is no longer just a maintenance detail. It is a major input in how your homeowners insurance is priced and structured.
2. How roof age affects your premiums and payouts
Roof age affects both what you pay and what you could receive if you ever need to file a claim.
Premium impacts
Several analyses and agency reports suggest that homes with older roofs often pay more. One insurance analytics source notes that homes with roofs over about 20 years old can see premiums increase by roughly 10 to 20 percent compared with similar homes with newer roofs.[^5]
Other patterns that are showing up across the market:[^1][^2][^6]
- Premiums tend to rise once a roof passes the 10 to 15 year mark
- Some insurers add wind or hail surcharges for older roofs
- Higher deductibles may apply for roof‑related claims, especially in storm‑prone regions
Even if you have never filed a claim, your renewal premium may climb simply because your roof crossed into a new age band.
Replacement Cost vs Actual Cash Value (ACV)
The type of coverage you have on the roof also changes with age.
- Replacement Cost Value (RCV): Pays what it actually costs to replace the roof with similar materials, subject to your deductible and policy limits
- Actual Cash Value (ACV): Pays the depreciated value of the roof, taking age and wear into account
For newer roofs, many insurers still offer full Replacement Cost coverage. But for older roofs, especially 20+ years, more carriers are switching to ACV or placing stricter limits on what they will pay.[^2]
Some carriers are now:
- Providing full replacement only for roofs below a certain age (often 10 or 15 years)
- Offering ACV only on older roofs, which can mean thousands of dollars less in a claim payout
- Limiting coverage specifically for wind and hail damage on aging roofs
An agency report from early 2025 notes that many companies no longer cover full roof replacement for older roofs, sometimes as young as 10 or 15 years, and will only pay the depreciated value or a limited amount instead.[^2]
Why it matters: Two neighbors could each have a $20,000 roof loss. The one with RCV coverage might get close to full replacement (minus deductible), while the one with ACV on a 20‑year‑old roof might receive only a small fraction of that cost.
Action step: Check your declarations page or talk to your agent about whether your policy covers the roof on an RCV or ACV basis, and ask at what age that might change.
3. Non‑renewals, inspections, and strict rules in certain states
In some regions, roof age is not just leading to higher prices. It is also causing non‑renewals and coverage denials, even when the roof looks “fine” to the homeowner’s eye.
Florida: 15‑year roofs under the microscope
Florida is one of the clearest examples of strict roof rules:
- Florida law (Chapter 627.7011) allows insurers to deny coverage for roofs over 15 years old unless the homeowner obtains an inspection showing at least five years of remaining useful life.[^4]
- Even with that inspection, companies may still raise rates or decline coverage.[^4]
- Regional roof and insurance experts report a trend of insurers refusing renewals or sharply raising premiums for roofs over 15 years, which has led some homeowners to replace roofs earlier than they otherwise would just to keep coverage.[^3]
Other high‑risk or costly states
Reports from roofing and insurance professionals indicate similar patterns elsewhere:
- In some hurricane‑prone or coastal states such as parts of Florida and Delaware, insurers may not write new homeowners policies for roofs older than 15 years.[^6]
- Roofs older than 20 years in these states are more likely to be limited to ACV coverage or face non‑renewal.[^2][^6]
Aerial imagery and roof condition disputes
Roof age is often tied to perceived condition. Some insurers are using aerial photos and other remote tools to evaluate roofs behind the scenes.
Regulators have pushed back on this. For example, in Connecticut, the state insurance department warned companies that they should not drop homeowners solely over cosmetic roof issues spotted from aerial imagery.[^7] Non‑renewals should be based on material degradation instead. Yet reports from Connecticut, New York, and California show that non‑renewals tied to roof condition and perceived age or wear are still happening.[^7]
What this means for you: Even if your roof is not leaking, insurers may consider it a problem once it crosses certain age thresholds or if imagery suggests worn shingles, curling, or patchwork repairs.
4. What to do if your roof is 10, 15, or 20+ years old
The good news is that you are not powerless. With a bit of planning and documentation, you can often improve your insurance options and avoid last‑minute surprises.
1) Find out your roof’s true age
If you do not know exactly how old your roof is:
- Check closing documents from when you bought the home for any roof replacement notes
- Look for old permits or receipts from roofers
- Ask the previous owner or your real estate agent if they have documentation
Insurers care about the installation date, not just when you purchased the home.
2) Get a professional roof inspection
Around key age milestones (10, 15, and 20 years):
- Schedule a licensed roofing contractor or roof inspector to assess the roof
- Ask for a written report that includes:
- Estimated remaining useful life
- Condition of shingles or other materials
- Photos of any wear or damage
In states like Florida, an inspection showing at least five years of remaining life may be required to keep coverage on roofs over 15 years old.[^4]
Even outside Florida, having a recent, detailed report can help when negotiating with an insurer or shopping for a new policy.
3) Complete preventive repairs before renewal
Many insurers look more favorably on older roofs that are well maintained.
Consider fixing:
- Missing, cracked, or curled shingles
- Exposed fasteners or flashing issues around chimneys, vents, and skylights
- Gutter problems that are causing water to back up under shingles
- Moss, algae, or debris buildup that can shorten roof life
Keep invoices and photos of repairs. If you receive an inspection notice or a non‑renewal warning, this documentation can be critical to show that the roof is structurally sound.
4) Talk to your agent before there is a problem
Do not wait for a surprise letter. Proactively:
- Ask your agent or insurer:
- At what age thresholds do your roof rules change?
- When does coverage switch from Replacement Cost to ACV (if it does)?
- Do you require inspections at 15 or 20 years?
- If your roof is approaching one of these thresholds, ask what you can do now to avoid non‑renewal or steep price hikes.
If your current insurer’s guidelines are especially strict for your roof type or age, it might be worth shopping around while you still have options.
5) Plan ahead for replacement
No roof lasts forever. Instead of waiting for a crisis:
- Talk with a trusted roofing contractor about realistic life expectancy for your specific material and climate
- Budget for replacement several years before the end of that expected life
- Ask roofers about materials that perform better in your local weather
Some insurers offer better rates or more generous coverage terms for roofs that use impact‑resistant materials in hail‑prone areas or for roofs installed to higher wind‑resistant standards in coastal zones.[^1][^8]
If you are already near a threshold (for example, a 17‑year‑old roof in a state where insurers start cutting coverage at 20 years), replacing a bit early can sometimes save money in the long run through both fewer problems and better insurance terms.
5. Buying a home? Make roof age a top priority
If you are shopping for a home, the roof is not just a maintenance concern. It can directly affect your ability to secure affordable insurance.
Here is how to protect yourself:
-
Ask early about roof age
During showings or in your agent’s initial questions, ask the seller:- When was the roof last replaced?
- What type of roofing material is installed?
- Are there any past roof or leak claims?
-
Review inspection reports carefully
Make sure the home inspection includes a detailed roof section. Consider a separate roof‑only inspection if the roof is older than 10 to 15 years. -
Talk to an insurance agent before you commit
Before you waive contingencies or finalize an offer:- Get insurance quotes based on the roof’s actual age and type
- Ask whether the policy will provide RCV or ACV on the roof
- Check if there are special deductibles or exclusions tied to wind or hail
-
Use roof condition in your negotiations
If the roof is older or near a worrisome age band:- Ask for a seller credit toward future roof replacement
- Request that the seller repair or replace problem areas before closing
- Factor potential higher premiums or earlier replacement into your offer price
A little homework now can help you avoid purchasing a “beautiful home with an uninsurable roof.”
Conclusion: Take control of your roof and your coverage
Roof age has quietly moved to center stage in the homeowners insurance world. Insurers are:
- Using 10, 15, and 20 year thresholds to adjust premiums and coverage
- Increasing the use of ACV instead of full replacement for older roofs
- In some states, refusing new policies or non‑renewing homes with older roofs, even when they appear in decent shape
You cannot stop your roof from aging, but you can:
- Know your roof’s age and understand your coverage type
- Maintain and document its condition with regular inspections and timely repairs
- Talk to your insurer before problems arise and shop around if guidelines feel too strict
- Plan ahead for replacement so you are not forced into rushed, expensive decisions just to keep coverage
If you are in the process of buying a home, these roof and insurance questions should be front and center alongside location, schools, and square footage.
HomeWalk is designed to help you walk through a home with confidence. Use HomeWalk to:
- Capture roof age, condition notes, and photos during your walkthrough
- Track inspection findings and repair estimates in one place
- Flag insurance‑related risks, like older roofs or signs of past leaks
The roof over your head should protect you, not threaten your coverage. With the right information and tools, you can stay ahead of roof‑age surprises and keep both your home and your insurance in good shape.
[^1]: New England Metal Roof. "How Roof Age Affects Homeowners Insurance Coverage & Costs." Available at: https://www.newenglandmetalroof.com/how-roof-age-affects-homeowners-insurance-coverage-costs/ [^2]: Connie Phillips Insurance. "Insurance Carriers Tighten Roof Guidelines" (2025). Available at: https://www.insurance-financial.net/2025/03/13/insurance-carriers-tighten-roof-guidelines/ [^3]: Florida Roof Advisors. "Roof Over 15 Years? Insurance May Be at Risk." Available at: https://flroofadvisors.com/roof-over-15-years-insurance-may-be-at-risk-what-central-florida-homeowners-must-do/ [^4]: Roof Coatings Manufacturers Association, summarizing Florida Statute 627.7011. "Insurance and Code Changes Could Cost Florida Homeowners Big." Available at: https://members.roofcoatings.org/news/Details/insurance-and-code-changes-could-cost-florida-homeowners-big-233631 [^5]: RAKE ML. "How Your Roof Type Impacts Home Insurance". Available at: https://www.rakeml.com/articles/how-your-roof-type-impacts-home-insurance-save-up-to-35-on-premiums [^6]: Reimagine Roofing. "How Roof Condition Affects Your Home Insurance Premiums" (2025). Available at: https://www.reimagineroofing.com/how-roof-condition-affects-your-home-insurance-premiums/ [^7]: CT Insider. "CT homeowners report nonrenewal over roof condition" (2025). Available at: https://www.ctinsider.com/business/article/ct-roof-insurance-nonrenewal-20789800.php [^8]: Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety (IBHS). "Short‑Term Roof Aging Farm" (2025). Available at: https://ibhs.org/hail/short-term-roof-aging-farm/